American Express National Bank is facing a federal lawsuit alleging it continued to report two business-card accounts as unpaid, charged-off debts after accepting settlement payments that purportedly resolved the balances in full. The complaint underscores the operational and compliance exposure furnishers face when settlement processing, dispute handling and Metro 2-style reporting controls do not align.
Allegations in the case
Plaintiff Brendan Pohl filed the suit against American Express National Bank in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California, alleging violations of the Fair Credit Reporting Act, the California Consumer Credit Reporting Agencies Act and the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. The case is Pohl v. American Express National Bank, Case No. 2:26-at-00984.
According to the complaint as summarized in published reports, Pohl opened two American Express business accounts in May 2023 and subsequently entered settlement agreements with the bank. American Express allegedly confirmed by email on Feb. 21, 2026, that the settlement payments had been processed successfully.
Pohl nevertheless alleges that American Express subsequently reported the accounts to Equifax, Experian and TransUnion as unpaid charged-off obligations, including unpaid balances. The complaint claims the bank continued to furnish the allegedly inaccurate data even after the consumer disputed it with each nationwide consumer reporting agency in February and March 2026.
The allegations are unproven, and American Express had not been found liable at the time of the report.
Dispute-investigation claims
The central FCRA allegation concerns American Express’s duties as a furnisher after receiving notice of a consumer dispute from a credit reporting agency. Pohl contends that the bureaus forwarded his disputes to American Express, but the bank verified the reporting rather than correcting it.
The lawsuit asserts that the disputed tradelines were still being reported as charged off as of at least May 2026. It also alleges that American Express updated or supplied the disputed information on an approximately 30-day cycle, potentially extending the consumer’s exposure to the claimed reporting error.
Pohl alleges that the reporting damaged his credit profile and caused loss of access to credit, higher credit costs, reputational harm and emotional distress. He seeks actual, statutory and punitive damages and has demanded a jury trial.
Why the case matters
A paid or settled account is not necessarily required to disappear from a consumer report immediately. Negative account history can generally remain reportable for the applicable reporting period. The key allegation here, however, is not merely that the accounts appeared after settlement; it is that they were allegedly furnished with a status and balances inconsistent with the settlement terms—namely, as unpaid charged-off debts despite full settlement payment.
For creditors, issuers and collection agencies, the case highlights several high-risk handoffs:
-
Settlement documentation should clearly state the remaining balance, intended account status and any reporting obligations once payment clears.
-
Payment-processing systems, collections platforms and credit-reporting workflows should be reconciled quickly after a settlement is fulfilled.
-
Dispute teams need access to the operative settlement agreement, proof of payment and account-history records before verifying a tradeline.
-
Furnishers should maintain auditable procedures showing how they investigate disputes and correct data found to be incomplete or inaccurate.
The allegations also illustrate why a dispute response cannot be treated as a purely automated verification event when a consumer presents evidence that an account has been settled. A settlement may properly result in reporting such as “settled,” “paid settlement,” or another accurate status depending on the agreement and reporting rules; it should not, however, be coded in a way that inaccurately suggests an unsatisfied balance remains.
Case details
The plaintiff is represented by David J. McGlothlin and Pamela E. Prescott of Kazerouni Law Group APC.






