In a financial landscape increasingly defined by digital innovation and fierce competition, a new report reveals a subtle yet profound challenge for financial institutions: many consumers, in their pursuit of control and clarity, are reverting to manual financial management, signaling a deeper need for fundamental simplicity over cutting-edge complexity.
The PYMNTS Intelligence report, “Loyalty Strategies FIs Need: Perks, Speed and Security,” sponsored by financial technology company FIS, highlights the escalating battle for consumer loyalty. Amid digital disruptors, the study emphasizes that financial institutions (FIs) must move quickly, think smarter and deliver more value to secure “top-of-wallet” status for their cards. Critical differentiators include enterprise rewards-based loyalty programs, ensuring seamlessness and security, and adopting hyper-personalized, multichannel communication as a strategic imperative.
However, the report also uncovers key consumer behaviors that underscore a potential disconnect between industry offerings and customer desires for ease and control:
Despite the proliferation of sophisticated digital tools, research indicates that nearly one-quarter of U.S. consumers now use spreadsheets to track money, and 65% pay bills manually each month. This surprising reversion to traditional methods is primarily driven by their perception that these processes are easier for them to understand (65%) and provide better control (57%) over their finances.
When it comes to fundamental payment choices, consumers heavily weigh convenience. Twenty-three percent of customers cite ease of use as their top priority when choosing a credit card, underscoring a foundational demand for frictionless and intuitive financial tools. Any perceived friction or delay is likely to prompt users to seek alternatives.
While personalization is frequently touted as a key to customer engagement, a significant gap exists between consumer desire and actual usage. And while 72% of customers report that personalization influences their choice of bank, a mere 3% utilize the personalization tools offered by their current providers. This suggests that many consumers feel overwhelmed by generic advertising (51%) and pressured to accept unsuitable products, indicating a need for more relevant and less intrusive personalized experiences.
Beyond these insights into consumer behavior, the report details a four-pronged strategy for financial institutions to bolster cardholder retention and foster growth. It stresses the vital role of elevated rewards programs, advocating for flexible, personalized options like cash equivalents and real-time redemption that offer immediate value.
The study asserts that airtight security is non-negotiable, with customers expecting robust protection against evolving fraud threats and a willingness to switch banks if security is perceived as inadequate. Lastly, the report underscores the strategic imperative of data-driven, targeted marketing, urging FIs to deploy AI to craft adaptive campaigns across various channels, including social media platforms like TikTok, to genuinely connect with younger demographics.
Secure Complaint RMAI Certified Broker
Defense and Compliance Attorneys
