Source: site
LONDON- UK credit card holders often face noticeably lower rewards compared with their American counterparts. While American consumers enjoy high-value points, statement credits, and premium perks, UK cards are restricted by regulatory caps and limited competition.
This disparity is primarily driven by interchange fee regulations, market structure, and issuer strategies. American Express and other US issuers can provide lucrative benefits due to higher transaction fees and competitive dynamics, whereas UK consumers see more modest rewards.
Why UK Credit Card Rewards Lag Behind the US
American Express Platinum Card holders in the United States recently saw an upgrade that added over $3,200 in annual statement credits for Uber, Resy dinner reservations, hotels, and streaming services.
Advertisement
The card also features a $200 annual fee increase and a 175,000 point sign-up bonus for $8,000 spent.
By contrast, the UK Platinum Card provides a 50,000 point sign-up bonus and £400 in restaurant statement credits, which is far less generous than the US offering. This difference arises from credit card regulation and market structure.
When a credit card is used, merchants pay an interchange fee to the card issuer. In the US, these fees often exceed 1.8% for standard cards and over 2% for premium cards such as Visa Signature or Infinite.
In the UK, EU-mandated caps restrict credit card interchange fees to 0.3% and debit card fees to 0.2%, drastically reducing issuer revenue available to fund rewards.
According to Head for Points, this fee cap reshaped the UK rewards market, leading to fewer co-branded credit cards and lower-value incentives.
Interchange Fees and Merchant Costs
Interchange fees are charged to merchants, not directly to consumers. Merchants often pay a blended fee, which includes interchange, network, and acquirer costs.
For small UK retailers, typical blended fees are around 1.5% for credit cards before the EU cap. Many merchants incorporated these costs into product pricing or enforced minimum card spend.
Cash handling carries costs as well. Retailers incur staff labor for bank deposits, insurance for cash storage, and bank deposit fees.
Despite these costs, interchange fees were historically a major source of funding for cardholder rewards.
In the U.S., card issuers can collect significantly higher fees. As a result, they can fund generous perks like premium hotel status, travel insurance, and high-value statement credits.
In the UK, capped fees mean issuers rely more on interest, late fees, and foreign exchange (FX) charges to generate income.
American Express and Vertical Integration
American Express operates uniquely as both issuer and network, allowing it to set its own fees. In the UK, however, court rulings forced Amex to reduce merchant fees on co-branded cards, although own-brand cards are unaffected.
This limits the funds available for UK rewards compared to US offerings.
Where UK credit cards once focused on high-spending travelers, the cap shifted bank priorities. Customers’ revolving balances or incurring FX charges became more profitable, while those paying in full were less lucrative.
Premium frequent travelers, who pay little interest, became less financially attractive under this structure.
EU Interchange Fee Regulation and Its Effects
Before 2015, UK issuers could charge average interchange rates around 0.8%, and EU member states had different rules.
The EU Interchange Fee Regulation standardized fees to 0.3% for credit cards and 0.2% for debit cards.
Variations still exist depending on transaction type and industry, reflecting fraud risk or default probability.
This reduction halved issuer revenue, forcing many rewards cards to close. MBNA withdrew Virgin Atlantic co-branded cards, followed by Emirates, Etihad, Lufthansa, United Airlines, American Airlines, Lloyds Bank, and TSB.
Retailer-backed cards, such as John Lewis, Marks & Spencer, Amazon, and charity cards, either reduced rewards or exited the market entirely. Cash-back rates dropped to as low as 0.1%, equivalent to 10p on £100 spent.
The cap also led to a decline in premium airline and hotel cards. Many cardholders who previously benefited from travel rewards no longer had access to lucrative offers, fundamentally reshaping the UK market.
Recovery and New Market Entrants
Despite this decline, the UK market has shown signs of revival. Virgin Atlantic relaunched its cards in 2018 through a joint venture with Virgin Money, pooling fees, interest, and FX charges to maintain viability.
In 2021, Avios partnered with Barclaycard to issue two new reward credit cards, functioning as a strategic loss leader to attract new customers.
Fintech firms are introducing innovative products. Currensea launched Hilton debit cards offering variable earning rates, with the Plus card granting Hilton Honors Gold Elite status. Business and SME cards, which are exempt from interchange fee caps, have also become increasingly popular.
Examples include British Airways Accelerating Business, American Express, and fintech Capital on Tap cards for small business owners.
These new entrants focus on sustainable reward structures, often blending points, status, and experience-based incentives rather than relying solely on cash-back or miles.
Big Spenders and Reward Limitations
Cards funded by 0.3% interchange fees struggle to profit from high spenders. Virgin Money and Barclaycard now impose monthly mile caps relative to credit limits.
This ensures the card remains economically viable but limits the rewards available for heavy users. Consequently, traditional premium travel cards for high-spending customers are largely absent in the UK.
The shift also prompted issuers to rethink marketing strategies. Rewards are increasingly seen as a tool for customer engagement rather than a direct profit center.
Offering status, exclusive experiences, or tiered benefits is more feasible under low interchange revenue conditions.
Role of Debit and Alternative Products
Debit cards are gaining relevance in the UK rewards space. Currensea’s Hilton debit cards challenge the notion that rewards require credit products.
These cards provide loyalty points and elite status, demonstrating that rewards can be successfully offered outside traditional credit mechanisms.
Corporate and SME credit cards also exploit regulatory exemptions. These cards maintain higher interchange rates, enabling issuers to fund more generous perks.
Despite this opportunity, SME-focused reward cards remain relatively limited compared to potential demand.
Lessons From the US Market
In the United States, credit card rewards remain exceptionally generous. US issuers benefit from higher interchange fees, less restrictive regulations, and intense market competition.
Sites similar to Head for Points in the US earn significant commissions on premium card applications, reflecting the lucrative economics behind high-reward programs.
Recent U.S. legislative proposals, like the Credit Card Competition Act, aim to introduce network choice for merchants and foster competition.
However, until such reforms pass, US cards will continue to deliver superior rewards compared to the UK, EU, and Australian markets.
Future Outlook
The UK co-brand and reward card market is slowly recovering. New issuers with lower overheads are willing to operate within reduced margins. Airline and hotel groups remain cautious, often overpricing points sales to banks, limiting the range of new cards.
Future growth will likely depend on creative reward structures:
- Status-based incentives (e.g., elite membership) instead of points
- Risk-sharing models between issuers and partners
- Fintech solutions offering flexible and tiered reward options
As legacy issuers such as American Express and Barclaycard focus less on new product innovation, fintech entrants and partnerships are poised to reshape the rewards landscape in 2025–2026.
Stay tuned with us. Further, follow us on social media for the latest updates.
Join us on Telegram Group for the Latest Aviation Updates. Subsequently, follow us on Google News
Upcoming Events
